Some notes on these notes: When I talk about focus accuracy, I am generally referring to shooting sports such as college football, volleyball and basketball. My shooting conditions for these sports ranges from outdoors under bright sunlight through dusk and indoors under gym lighting. My gym recently received a lighting upgrade, which allows for available light shooting at ISO 800, 1/125, f/2.8 (this is an estimate and will be updated the next time I check the facility).
Sigma 8mm f/4
Fast on D2x, D200, D7000. Inherent depth-of-field provides leeway for focusing errors. Fairly sharp wide open, f/5.6 and f/8 provide a safe zone to eliminate any wide-open softness. Requires chromatic aberration correction for best results. In Camera Raw, start with -61 for red/cyan. Lightroom 4 era Camera Raw automatically corrects most CA, though some is still visible.
AF Nikkor 10.5mm f/2.8D (DX)
Fast on D2x, D7000. Ridiculously short minimum focus distance, allowing for steep perspective. In progress.
Nikkor 20mm f/2.8 AIS
In progress.
Nikkor 28mm f/2 AI
In progress.
AF Nikkor 35mm f/2D
Fast on D2x, D200, D70/D70s. Accurate wide open on most bodies, although low-contrast rendering and overall softness may create confusion. Focusing discipline required for best results. Clearer starting at f/2.8.
AF Nikkor 50mm f/1.8D
Fast on D2x, D200, D70/D70s. Accurate wide open on D2x, D200. Focusing discipline required on D70/D70s when wide open. Wide-open photos are somewhat low-contrast with an overall soft look. Much clearer starting at f/2.5.
Nikkor 50mm f/1.4 AIS
In progress.
Nikkor 50mm f/2 AI
The kit lens of the day for the Nikkormat. At f/2, overall softness lends a dreamy look to photos. Careful focusing reveals acceptable sharpness and fairly soft bokeh. Stopping down improves sharpness immensely. Maximum sharpness on D2x at f/8-f/11. Still sharp at f/16, but slightly degraded from diffraction. Don't hesitate to use minimum aperture if depth-of-field is necessary. Soft look at f/2 has great aesthetic potential.
AF Nikkor 85mm f/1.4D
Outstanding wide-open, and even better stopped down. I shoot studio portraits in the f/2.8-5.6 range and environmental portraits from f/1.4-5.6.
Fast and accurate on D2x. Off-center focusing is possible. So far, the D2x has been the most consistent in getting accurate focus.
Fast on D200. Off-center focusing is hit-or-miss. Fairly accurate with center AF sensor. Focusing discipline required in low-contrast lighting.
Fast on D7000. Higher resolution sensor requires more focusing discipline. Off-center focusing possible.
Fast on D90. Under moderate lighting, obtaining accurate focus at large apertures is difficult.
AF-S 300mm f/4
Fast and accurate on D2x. More focusing discipline required than with 80-200, particularly with moving objects, due to narrow depth-of-field. Sharp wide-open, and sharper stopped down. Subjects at extreme distances sometimes require manual tweaking (if available, focus manually in live view).
Less accurate on D200.
AF-S 300mm f/4 + TC-14
Effective f/5.6 aperture reduces speed and accuracy on D2x. Slightly soft wide-open, recommend f/6.3 as starting point. As usual with teleconverters, avoid unless closer approach to subject is not possible.
Tokina 12-24mm f/4 (DX)
Fast on D2x, D200,
D70/D70s. Accurate on all bodies, although focusing discipline required to ensure proper subject is used to acquire focus (unintentionally in-focus backgrounds are more likely operator error). Slight softness wide-open may create confusion.
Chromatic aberration is complex and difficult to entirely manually correct. Good results with Kirk Douglas's D90 lens profile in Camera Raw. No problems with built-in profile from Lightroom 4 era Camera Raw.
AF Nikkor 80-200 f/2.8D
Fast and accurate on D2x, even in low to moderate gym lighting. Off-center focusing is possible. Moving objects track well.
Slower on D200 and D70/D70s. Off-center focusing is hit-or-miss. Less able to track moving objects. Under moderate to bright light, obtaining accurate focus is fairly easy.
Feel free to work at f/2.8, but be careful with focusing. A bit softer than smaller apertures, but still quite good. Great results at f/4-f/11.
AF-S Nikkor 18-70mm f/3.5-4.5 (DX)
Fast and accurate on D2x. Fast on D200, D70/D70s and D7000. Accurate throughout focal range. Focusing discipline a must at wide angle, wide-open, with busy backgrounds (unintentionally in-focus backgrounds are more likely operator error). Slightly soft wide-open at 18mm. Fairly sharp wide-open at 70mm. Sharp at f/5.6 for all focal lengths. Tracking moving subjects less accurate than 80-200.
